Yvette
Mimieux, was she hot, or what?
What
a great movie. I was only 14 when I first saw it at
the old Lakeshore Theater in Jacksonville. Rod Taylor
portrayed H.G. Wells traveling through time in this
1960 MGM academy award winning film.
In
the future, after some unknown "Great
Catastrophe" had destroyed our civilization, the
time traveler meets the beautiful Weena (an Eloi woman
played by Yvette Mimieux)…and, in the end, they find
themselves fighting for their lives against the evil
Morlocks in their underworld city below the great
stone sphinx.
Time
travel fascinated me. What if…just what if you could
see the future?
I
am convinced that the future will be the result of the
choices that we make today. Most importantly, we need
to be acutely aware of what the future is not
going to be.
Why
in the world would anyone in his or her right mind bet
on the factory version of what the future holds for
the retail automobile industry? These people
collectively have a record for screw-ups that defies
rational thought.
Let’s
pretend for a moment that General Motors is successful
in dismantling and destroying their retail dealer
network. In the immediate future, I believe that they
plan to replace their physical dealerships with
Internet sales. Excuse me folks… "That just
ain’t gonna happen."
So
far the Internet is just a lot of noise. Recent
research by reputable firms has proven that the
Internet hasn’t accomplished one additional sale of
even one additional car.
We
are already looking at the second generation of
Internet vendor. In my observations, the first
generation, the referral services…a fancy name for
Internet Brokers…it just didn’t happen. The
AutoByTel and AutoByInternet type of customer, in my
opinion, proved to be a major nonevent. My experience
with Internet referral customers was that they were
just a sophisticated telephone inquiry. The more
information they were given, it appeared that there
was less statistical possibility that they would
actually purchase a car from the dealer that provided
them with the statistics. In effect we gave these
non-qualified consumers all of the information they
needed to purchase elsewhere or not-at-all. The
Internet referral closing ratios were terrible. Of
course, I read and heard all of the propaganda about
that supposed dealer somewhere in the sticks who was
racking up profits from Internet referral sales
…BUT…In reality, I believe it was a bust.
If
a dealer accidentally did sell one of these grinders a
car, chances are that they might, conceivably, become
the legendary "Customer from Hell".
Personally, if I were a dealer, I wouldn’t want some
of these people to ever show up in my showroom.
In
the end it is still all about relationship marketing.
When we’re talking about buying a car…we’re
talking about a thirty or forty thousand-dollar
investment here.
Last
month they held the official grand opening of the Mall
of Georgia less than ten miles from where I live in
Atlanta. This mall is incredible, rivaling the Mall of
America in Minneapolis as one of the greatest largest
malls in the country. You know folks, they actually
had traffic jams and they actually had to increase
parking areas and shuttles to the mall.
Yes,
the Internet is someday going to be a major factor in
automobile sales. AND…yes, you had better become
involved in technology-based commerce. BUT…don’t
be fooled into believing that it’s going to replace
the hands-on, service-oriented, bricks and mortar
dealerships. An automobile is not a commodity. It is a
major investment decision in most people’s lives.
They want to see it, drive it, smell it, and have the
reassurance of looking into the eyes of whom they’re
dealing with.
If
there’s one thing you can be sure of about the
Internet Automobile Sales Revolution, it’s
this…Almost everybody in the game is
"buggering" up those figures. There is more
statistical "bullcrap" being fed to the
dealers, the public, and the media than you’d find
in an AutoNation Press release.
Speaking
of AutoNation, (one of my favorite subjects) In an
October 29th article on the back page of
the Money Section of USA Today…Wayne Huizenga was
quoted as saying, " The investor does not believe
in the value of the franchises that we do have, and
they do not believe in the strength of our
company."
Wow!
Wayne and I do agree on one thing…if the
manufacturers are allowed to compete with their
dealers and sell cars directly to the public, on the
Internet or otherwise, those franchises you’re
holding are going to be absolutely worthless.
AutoNation Dealerships are only going to be worth
their real estate value if the manufacturers win this
battle. The catch is that AutoNation stock is stuck at
$10.00 per share…or less…much less…as long as
Wall Street realizes that they have not increased the
profitability of the franchises. Now, with General
Motors and Ford evidently threatening to totally
obliterate the value of their investment value, I am
sure Wayne and company are trembling.
Remember
this, AutoNation and CarMax were those pioneers who
were here to teach us all about the future of the
retail automobile business.
What
AutoNation actually taught us was how to reduce your
stock’s value by thirty-five per cent in the
all-time record automobile retail sales year in
history.
As
I write these words, CarMax is sitting at a whopping 2
7/8ths per share. My kid could buy CarMax stock with
his lunch money and still eat well.
Now
these people and Ford and General Motors actually feel
someone should take them seriously about the wave of
the future?
I
told you seven months ago that Ford was losing market
share to General Motors and Chrysler in Tulsa as a
result of their goofy one-price, no-haggle, happy-clappy,
Excel 2000, venture into Tulsa Oklahoma…well…guess
what? John Macdonald, senior VP of sales at
Daimler-Chrysler just confirmed that Chrysler Dealers
picked up 3.5% market share in Tulsa. He apparently
credits Ford Motor Company’s ineptitude at retailing
for the boost in Tulsa. As for General Motors’
ventures into retailing, he was quoted as saying…
"You talk about dumb and dumber." (GM in
comparison to Ford)
If
I were a dealer, I would just love the position
Chrysler is taking. They are going to own the market
if GM and Ford keep dicking around with the retail
process.
The
biggest single thing that the dealers have not
accomplished is that the states have not adequately
strengthened their franchise laws to protect the
dealers. There is a media prejudice out there that
must be educated and won over. Somehow, the left wing
liberal partitions within the media believe that the
dealers are the reason that car prices are so high.
I
am ashamed that some of you have not had the guts to
stand up for your dealerships. If you lose everything
you have ever worked for without a whimper or putting
up a fight…then you deserve that.
Those
who suck up to the factories will not be spared. Ask
Jim Willingham if you can trust the factories?
If
I were a dealer organization, I would get to the
stockholders. Remember Stempel.
If
the manufacturers ever win the battle to eliminate
their dealers, the public is most certainly going to
be screwed here. The manufacturers have made record
profits in the face of declining market shares. What
does that tell you? The dealers are not to blame; most
of them are barely making a profit. It is the
manufacturer that is gouging the public. If the media
thinks the manufacturers are going to give the public
a price break, they better think again. The
independent, competitive automobile dealer is only
thing that has held prices down for the consumer.
AND…if the manufacturers ever were to eliminate
their dealers, the level of service and quality would
drop proportionately. Then every dealership might be
able to achieve those stellar CSI levels similar to
the Rydell Group in Southern California.
If
you are a GM dealer, why don’t you inquire into how
Rydell’s CSI is doing in California? They should be
proud of it…after all this is the factory model!
(Remember) I was on record in this magazine more than
a year ago as saying that the Southern California
market would kick Wes’ butt all the way back to the
frozen tundra. I ain’t wrong yet, not by a long
shot. Even with an obvious factory "Leg Up",
he’s out of his league.
Speaking
of Wes Rydell, they’ve now created the East Coast
equivalent…Joe Laham. What we have here, in my
humble personal opinion, is just another turtle on top
of a fencepost who is swearing that no one stuck him
up there. Of course, GM spokes-marionettes are saying,
"There will be no favoritism!" (Regarding
Laham getting preferred inventory that no one else can
get) Sure, big guys, we believe that. Just ignore the
little man behind the curtains pulling the strings.
Laham evidently, has a fairly high opinion of his
retail ability to give vehicles away. Of course, I
know what his retail record was before the factory
came aboard.
This
is sort of like trying to believe that GMC truck
division isn’t actually sending letters to customers
in another dealer’s market area asking them to shop
at Rydell Auto Group. No Favoritism!
Oh
well! Looking into the future is easy if you use the
track record of the past as a barometer. General
Motors is a decaying remnant of past glory. Ford is a
skyrocket that will probably fizzle and burnout. Both
of these companies are have become distracted and have
lost that "Eye on the Ball" concentration.
They have become preoccupied with changing the retail
process when it truthfully was never broken. The
beneficiaries will be the import manufacturers,
including Daimler-Chrysler, as long as they continue
to build superior product and stand out of their
dealer’s way and let them retail the vehicles. What
we are seeing here, sadly enough, could be the
ultimate demise of Ford and GM.
Oh
well, raising a snifter of vintage Remy-Martin to Rod
Taylor and Yvette Mimieux (God, she was hot)
"Here’s to fighting off the evil Morlocks…or
any other evil marketing Czars for that matter!"